Question 2
Social Services Eligibility
"Do you support the Government of Alberta introducing a law mandating that only Canadian citizens, permanent residents and individuals with an Alberta-approved immigration status will be eligible for provincially funded programs, such as health care, education and other social services?"
Why You Should Vote No
This question would strip essential services from people who are legally present in Canada under federal authorization, paying taxes, and contributing to Alberta's economy. It targets the most vulnerable workers and invites costly legal challenges.
Key Numbers
These People Are Here Legally, With Federal Permission
The people who would be cut off by this law (refugee claimants, asylum seekers, certain temporary residents) are not here illegally. They are in Canada with authorization from the federal government under federal law. Cutting off their healthcare or their children's access to schools does not make them leave; it makes their situation more desperate and more costly to manage.
Refugee claimants, for example, have a constitutional right to file for protection under the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act and are entitled to basic services while their claim is processed. Denying them healthcare does not resolve their claim; it creates humanitarian crises in Alberta communities.
Sources
APTN News. (2026). Alberta announces date of referendum.
Immigration News Canada. (2026). Alberta referendum 2026: Immigration rules and services.
Temporary Workers Pay Taxes and Deserve Corresponding Services
Temporary foreign workers in Alberta pay provincial and federal income taxes, Canada Pension Plan contributions, and Employment Insurance premiums, the same as any other resident. They contribute to the very programs this question would deny them access to.
Alberta's 27.7% immigrant population includes tens of thousands of workers in healthcare, agriculture, the oil sands, and construction who arrived on temporary work permits. Denying them access to services while they continue to pay into the system is not a question of fiscal responsibility. It is a question of whether contributions to the system entitle workers to its benefits.
Sources
Government of Alberta. (n.d.). Alberta labour force profiles: Immigrants in the labour force.
InfoImmigration. (2026). Alberta immigration referendum 2026: Shocking risks ahead.
Denying Healthcare Creates Public Health Risks for All Albertans
Communicable diseases do not check immigration status. When workers in food production, elder care, or construction cannot access healthcare, they delay treatment. This puts their colleagues, clients, and communities at risk. Unaddressed infections spread; untreated injuries become disabilities; children kept out of school fall further behind.
From a purely practical standpoint, emergency rooms become the default when preventive care is denied. Emergency care is far more expensive than primary care. This policy would ultimately cost the healthcare system more, not less, while making Alberta a less healthy place to live.
Sources
InfoImmigration. (2026). Alberta immigration referendum 2026: Shocking risks ahead.
It Will Face Immediate Charter Challenges
Section 15 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms protects everyone in Canada from discrimination. Section 7 guarantees the right to life, liberty, and security of the person. Courts have previously struck down similar provincial measures that denied services based on immigration status when the denial threatened life or security.
Any law implementing this referendum result would be immediately challenged. Alberta would spend millions in legal fees defending legislation that is unlikely to survive judicial review, while the people it targets remain in limbo. A "Yes" vote does not create a working policy. It creates years of expensive litigation.
Sources
JURIST. (2026, February). Alberta to hold referendum on provincial immigration control and constitutional amendments.
Share this page